Good morning!
I replaced that valve diaphragm with Viton 60 sheet material I sourced from eBay.
The material came in a 3 pack 6" X 6" X 5/64" (.0781"). 1 piece each of Viton 60, 70 and 90 durometer.
I selected the 60 because it had the flexibility that the diaphragm needed and sealed perfectly.
I have had it installed for several years with out any leaking or other problems.
I don’t remember what I paid for it but it is basically scrap material left over from
some manufacturing process so it wasn’t much.
Hope it helps you!
Respectfully,
Bob