If the sealing surfaces are clean and straight, I think I’d use Permatex Anaerobic Flange Sealant, P/N 51531, on it. This stuff is similar to the old OMC Gel Seal and since it is anaerobic, it will set up in the absence of air. Permatex does have a copper based primer to compliment it if you are in a hurry but it will set up overnight without it.
Yes, like Stanley said, brown paper… I use the common brown paper grocery bag… Good stuff. I usually give it a light spray of gasket sealer, both sides… let it dry thoroughly before installing.
Thanks. Originally there s no gasket between the top and bottom portions of the crankcase. Adding a paper gasket will mess up the crank shaft play… have you had success adding a gasket between the split portion of the crankcase?
Here’s parts list for P35 showing gaskets in question. #17-44,17-45. All the early opposed twin Johnsons I have worked on have these thin paper gaskets.