Hoping someone might be able to turn me onto a prop that will fit my 1958 evinrude 5.5 fisherman 5516 as my original finally broke a blade any leads on one reasonably priced would be greatly appreciated
Well, that part number is: 376968
Be very careful, the prop for the 7.5hp will fit, but is the wrong prop. It is very easy to confuse the props, they look pretty much identical, but the 7.5hp prop has a little more pitch….
I looked on ebay, there was one, but it was priced way too high.
You might try the classified ads here….
If you are looking at buying a new one, here is one source with a selection – you will want one the 6-1/2 or 7-1/2 inch pitch for your 5-1/2 – note the 2 and 3 blade column:
Dave